Pantomime Traditions: Why We Do It That Way

Pantomime traditions are the part of the job nobody explains, because everyone in the room already knows what a songsheet is and roughly when the ghost turns up. What tends to go unsaid is where any of it came from, and once you know that, a few of the conventions stop looking like rules and start looking like tools. I spent years playing panto from the pit before I ever thought about its origins and started to research it myself. This is the version I wish somebody had given me back then.

The Fairy Enters Stage Right, the Villain Stage Left

This is the one that still catches me out, even after years of doing this. The good fairy comes on from stage right, which is the audience’s left. The villain comes on from stage left, the audience’s right. They stay on their own sides, and the good fairy usually gets the last word from hers.

The reason is medieval. In the mystery plays, the right of the stage stood for Heaven and the left for Hell, and pantomime inherited the geography along with the morality. Nobody’s staged a mystery play in this country for centuries, and the convention has carried on regardless.

I’d keep it, and not for the sake of tradition. An audience reads the stage before it hears a word, and if your villain arrives from the same side as your fairy you’ve quietly told them the two characters belong together. It costs nothing to get right and it does real work in the first five minutes.

Why the Dame Is a Man

The commonly repeated reason, that women were barred from the stage, is wrong. By the time this convention took hold, in the early 1800s, they hadn’t been for well over a century. Actresses of the day mostly had neither the years nor the inclination to play unglamorous older comic women, so middle-aged male performers took the parts instead, and audiences found a man in the costume funnier than a woman in it. That’s the practical reason, and it’s a better story than the ban, probably why the ban keeps getting repeated instead.

What she looks like has kept moving even after the convention itself settled. Victorian Dames were plainly dressed, a man in a frock representing the woman next door, one costume doing the whole evening. Danny La Rue changed that more than anyone else in the twentieth century, and by the time he retired a Dame could reasonably run through 22 costume changes in one show, some of it beaded and sequinned by the yard. He played Widow Twankey himself, which is a role our Aladdin still carries. Cinderella’s Ugly Sisters are the Dame role under a different name, and Peter Robbins and Nigel Ellacott played the pair together in 28 productions across 26 years.

The Dame is the comic engine and generally the most demanding part in the script, not a costume gag on its own. In Cinderella there are two of them, which doubles both the opportunity and the risk.

The Animal Nobody Can See Out Of

The skin part is old and it is awkward, and both facts are the point. Two performers in one costume, one at the front, one behind, coordination not guaranteed.

It survives because an audience finds a pantomime animal funny before it does anything, which is rare. Cast it properly rather than filling it; the back half does most of the physical work and none of the seeing. Pat the Cow in our Jack and the Beanstalk is a two-person job that moos rather than speaks, a decision about comedy rather than a shortcut.

It’s Behind You

The ghost scene has a fixed structure, and the structure is the tradition rather than the ghost.

Characters sing a verse. The figure enters behind them. The house shouts. They turn, find nothing, and go back to the song. It happens again, and this time one of them is frightened off. The pattern repeats, thinning the stage one character at a time, until the reversal that makes the scene work, which is when the Dame turns to the ghost, and it runs offstage instead.

The thing creeping up doesn’t have to be a ghost. In our Dick Whittington it’s Eileen the cat, and in The Little Mermaid and Pinocchio it’s jellyfish and sea monsters respectively. The setting decides the monster; the structure stays put.

The Slosh Scene, and Why It Is Always the Dame

Wallpaper paste, custard, flour, a decorating job or a baking one, or in our Goldilocks and the Three Bears a purpose-built machine that fires the custard pies on cue. Our Hansel and Gretel runs it as the more traditional baking version instead, since Dame Kitty Kipling is a baker before she’s anything else. The mess is the tradition and it’s at least as old as the harlequinade, which ended most evenings with exactly this kind of knockabout before the fairy tale took over the bill.

It falls to the Dame because the Dame is the character an audience has already agreed to enjoy suffering. That sounds unkind and it’s how the form works. Nobody wants to watch the principal girl get a pie in the face.

The Songsheet and the Walkdown

These two do a specific job, and it’s easy to assume the wrong one. The songsheet’s real job is turning the audience from watching into a fully included part of the production. Filling five minutes is incidental, and the scene works far better if the show has already asked them for something earlier and got it. By the time you reach the songsheet it should be the fourth or fifth thing you’ve asked of them, not the first.

The walkdown is the older of the two and the more formal. A rhyming couplet each, in pairs, everyone in their best, building to a line the whole company delivers together. It’s the last thing an audience sees and the cheapest thing in the show to get wrong, because it needs nothing but rehearsal.

From Drury Lane to the Palladium

The line from the Victorian stage to what you’d see at Christmas today runs through one building. The London Palladium’s first pantomime was Dick Whittington and His Cat, in 1914, and Cinderella followed the year after. By the 1950s it had Julie Andrews playing Cinderella and a Mother Goose written by Spike Milligan and Eric Sykes, which tells you how far the celebrity-casting habit had already travelled from Augustus Harris’s day.

The tradition nearly died there. Musicals pushed pantomime out through the 1980s, and the last one ran in 1987. It came back in 2016 under producer Michael Harrison, with a Cinderella that reset the model the big commercial pantos still run on, and a recurring company of star names including Julian Clary, Nigel Havers and Paul Zerdin and additional celebrity headliners joining each year. It’s a different economics from what Augustus Harris was doing in the 1880s, but it’s the same instinct, a famous name draws a crowd, just at a scale no Victorian manager could have attempted.

Which of These You Actually Have to Keep

Fewer than you might think. An audience will forgive a missing slosh scene; it won’t forgive a show with nothing to shout at, a Dame who isn’t funny, or a walkdown that looks like the cast is leaving a meeting. My own rule is that a convention earns its place by giving the audience a job, which the shouting, the boo, the songsheet and the entrance sides all do. Everything else is craft, tradeable for time when a rehearsal schedule slips.

If you want the fuller chronology all of this sits inside, there’s a separate post on the history of pantomime, and the real story behind one of panto’s stranger character names is in Who Is Dandini?, and the genuinely ancient folklore underneath one of the stories itself is in The Surprising History of Jack and the Beanstalk. If you’d rather see how the conventions sit inside an actual script, every title is free to read before you commit: request a Perusal Script, look through the full range of scripts, or start at the home page.

Previous
Previous

How to Run a Successful Pantomime Box Office

Next
Next

Beauty and the Beast Pantomime Characters: A Complete Guide